Advantages and Disadvantages of Parliamentary Law Making Process - PDFCOFFEE.COM

Advantages and Disadvantages of Parliamentary law making process One of the advantages of parliamentary law making is sc

Views 380 Downloads 36 File size 317KB

Report DMCA / Copyright

DOWNLOAD FILE

Recommend Stories

Citation preview

Advantages and Disadvantages of Parliamentary law making process One of the advantages of parliamentary law making is scrutiny. The legislative process is very thorough as there are three reading and two stages which take place in both Houses of Parliament. This offers several chances for debate, scrutiny and amendments, ensuring that any mistakes or poor drafting can be corrected. Also parliamentary law making is democratic. MPs in the House of Commons are democratically elected (voted by the public) to make laws for the U.K. During the debates on the proposed law each MP should have the opportunity to put forward the view of his/her voters. However members of the House of Lords are not democratically elected, so they cannot vote a Bill that has the approval of the Commons. The Government has a lot of power; it controls the parliament timetable for debate and is likely to win at each stage unless the parties own MPs vote against it. This is democratic as the Government are made up

of

ministers

who

have

been

elected

by

the

public.

Another advantage is the House of Lords as it acts as a checking guide to ensure that the House of Commons

do

not

just

pass

laws

that

fit

the

House

of

Commons

political

approach.

All MPs and Lords have the opportunity to introduce new Bills. This helps for controversial bills e.g. marriage Act 1994 which allowed marriages to take place in places other than a church and Registry Offices.

Disadvantages A disadvantage of parliamentary law making is that it is undemocratic as neither the Queen nor the House of Lords are elected, thus, the unelected House of Lords should not have the power to delay Bills that

have

been

approved

by

the

democratically

elected

House

of

Commons.

Another disadvantage is Government control as the Government has a majority of MPs in the House of Commons; it can vote out any private members Bills that does not fit its political agenda. The Government is too powerful as it is able to by pass the House of Lords views via Parliament Act. The process is slow as a Bill has to go through many readings and stages as is not appropriate when important laws need to be made quickly. Although the Royal Assent has become a formality this is somewhat a futile stage and makes the whole legislative process more time consuming. When drafting a Bill, parliamentary draftsmen use words and phrases that are confusing, unclear and over elaborate. 75% of cases in the House of Lords involve issues over interpretation of Acts of Parliament. Language and structural issues also make the law inaccessible for ordinary people.